The 2025 Oscars sparked controversy after Mikey Madison won Best Lead Actress for Anora, a romantic comedy. Many expected Demi Moore to win for her haunting performance in The Substance, and social media erupted with backlash. Fans called the decision a “slap in the face”, highlighting Moore’s visible disappointment.
Despite the outrage, some praised Madison while expressing sympathy for Moore. Horror fans were particularly frustrated, arguing the genre is often overlooked. Adding to the debate, a lip reader suggested Moore muttered “nice” during the announcement, masking her disappointment.
Moore’s transformative role as a fading celebrity in The Substance had already earned her a Golden Globe and a SAG Award, further fueling claims she was “robbed” of the Oscar. While the Academy ruled in Madison’s favor, Moore’s supporters believe her long career still deserves an Oscar-worthy ending.
Beyond the award, Moore’s red carpet look also sparked discussion. Dressed in a custom Armani Privé gown, she stunned in silver, but some online speculated about changes in her appearance. Critics questioned whether her face looked altered, while others defended her, calling her “classy and timeless.”
Though Madison secured the award, Moore remained a standout presence at the 97th Academy Awards, celebrating the night with grace.
